When I first got my iPad 2, I knew that a main use was going to be note-taking at work. Now as a researcher who more or less writes for a living, I can say I’m a pretty fast typist. This is a skill I depend on to do my work efficiently. However, this is a skill I’ve only really had to master on a full sized keyboard.
Knowing that I would be taking notes using my iPad, I wondered whether I would need a keyboard. I had seen the Scosche and Kensington keyboards sold on iPhoneAccessories.com but before I made the investment, I wanted to give the iPad’s keyboard a try to see if perhaps I could do without. And if not, then which of the two would fit my needs best, a case that has a keyboard or just an external keyboard? Don’t get me wrong; I love having all the cool accessories. I have at least two of everything. I just didn’t want to have to pull out the keyboard every time I was in meeting or doing data collection.
Still, with the iPad, there is the issue of the auto correct. As magical as this function can be, there are times when it doesn’t recognize what I want to type. In a regular meeting, I have time to go back and correct it, but when I’m doing data collection, like taking notes at an interview, this function can be really frustrating because I don’t have the time and luxury to correct it right there on the spot. For this reason, I wanted to see if the keyboard would in fact be necessary.
So I decided to do a test. I was about to start doing interviews with several members of an organization to ask them what their roles and responsibilities are and to get a sense of their scopes of work. I was going to conduct at least 6 interviews so I decided I would do three on the iPad and 3 on a regular laptop to simulate keyboard use. Here is what I found:
iPad without the full sized keyboard – Pros:
- Easier/lighter to carry
- Battery lasted longer (believe it or not!)
- Easier to send the notes via email when on the go (of course you need 3G for this)
- Less intimidating for the interviewee
Laptop (AKA full sized keyboard simulation) – Pros
- Accuracy: I am more used to typing on the keyboard so I made fewer mistakes
- Less time to clean up the notes and try to figure out what the auto correct function mistakenly “corrected”
Decision:
I’ve decided that since accuracy in my work is a necessity, I’m going to need an iPad keyboard. I decided to come to a compromise and get the Scosche external keyboard for use when I’m collecting data and need to type fast and accurately without the ability to go back (for example, during an interview). Then for regular work meetings, I can leave the iPad external keyboard in my iPad bag and simply type on the iPad’s internal keyboard.














